Morning Reading: 9/8/06

Eventually we’ll all get a turn at being CEO of Gateway.

Mashable reports on Faketown 2.0 (you just have to love the 2.0).  Sounds like Webkinz for grown-ups.  Come to think of it, so does Second Life.

C|Net on getting fit with Web 2.0.

Never shoot your wife’s pet chicken.

Remember back in February, I made fun of a friend of mine who wanted to buy cargo containers and turn them into housing for retirees?  Somebody beat him to it.

Mark Evans reports that Shutterfly has filed for an IPO.

Tags: ,

Freddy vs Jason: On YouTube

freddy jason

Not since Godzilla vs King Kong, or Alien vs Predator or at least Pee Wee Herman vs Mr. Rogers have we seen a battle like the one that took place today in the blogosphere. Teens of people sat glued to their computer screens as Freddy and Jason went to battle over how many millions of dollars of annual net revenue could be generated by that IPO-in-waiting, YouTube.

Freddy came out swinging, with an estimate of around $150 million, thereby making everyone associated with YouTube giddy with Monopoly money joy. About adding a 10 second ad to the beginning of videos- Freddy says that won’t reduce YouTube’s user base or the amount of views because 10 seconds isn’t very long and- I’m almost too excited to type- users might be able to tag their favorite ads. I can’t wait to retirement age so I can spend all my time tagging ads.

Imagine Freddy backing Jason into a corner by beating him over the head with orange $500 bills.

But then, in true Hollywood fashion, Jason flipped Freddy over his shoulders and started chasing him with a chainsaw made of low CPM rates and content provider lawsuits. He lunged at Freddy, wielding his business acumen like a mighty sword:

If I was a video holder I would go to YouTube and say you can have all our stuff for an $8 CPM and you keep all the upside and we want an upfront, non-refundable advance of $3M a year.

And then he tried to finish the battle with a thrusting irony: “If YouTube did that they would be a real business. Of course, of other folks tried that and never got there.”

But Freddy ducked and the battle raged on in the comments to both posts. Freddy, correctly, calling Jason a “YouTube hater.” Jason parrying with another “pay users for their content” speech.

It has been a mighty battle, not yet won or lost. Meanwhile the onlookers place their bets and wait for the sequel.

Tags: ,

Xanga Gets Popped: Who’s Next?

I said back in May that if the social networking sites didn’t start taking meaningful steps to make their web sites safer, particularly where kids are concerned, that someone- namely the government- was going to start doing it for them.

First we had the so-called My-Space Law.

Now we have fines. Big ones. Mashable reports today that social networking site Xanga has been fined $1 million for violating the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA). What should be scary about this is the fact that Xanga is reported to have better privacy features than most social networking sites- probably because it is geared more for young people.

COPPA applies to the online collection of personal information from children under 13. It contains requirements for a privacy policy as well as the contents thereof. It attempts to ensure parental consent before such information is collected, with consent to be evidenced by a signed form, a verifiable credit card number, a telephone call, or an email with a digital signature. COPPA is the basis for the birth date question you see when registering for many web sites.

On the one hand, this looks to me like a warning shot across the bow of a bunch of social networking sites. Many will have a knee-jerk reaction against anything that keeps a user from content, but I’m on record as a supporter of any reasonable requirements that will keep kids safe on the often unsafe internet. Any reasonable requirement.

It’s an open question, however, about whether COPPA actually does what it is intended to do, since it seems the only requirement is to refuse to register someone who admits to being underage. If we lied to buy beer in the 70s, why do we assume kids will tell the truth when registering at web sites in the oughts?

According to Mashable, Xanga’s mistake was not checking the user-supplied birth date for those who checked the “not under 13” box. Checking the box does not eliminate the need to do the math on the birth date. So those who checked the box but supplied a birth date showing themselves to be under age should have been refused.

Checking the birth date is one line in the code. So unless there’s evidence that Xanga was trying to make it even easier for a kid to lie, this seems to me like a million dollar technical glitch, as opposed to a big win for internet safety.

Tags: ,

Jamming Those Pesky Cell Phones

At lunch today, there was a very popular lady sitting at the next table. I know she is popular because her cell phone rang about every 3 minutes. She’s also deaf. I know that because every time it rang, the rest of us dove under our tables, mistaking her insanely loud cell phone ring for a civil defense warning.

While I was irritated that this lady couldn’t turn her phone off or put it in silent mode for the 45 minutes it took her to eat lunch, I can’t support any effort to ban or jam cell phones.

Why? Because I am a parent. And because any legislation would likely substitute one problem for another. And because the restaurant and movie industries, which are desperately trying to draw customers to restaurants and theaters, probably wouldn’t enforce the law anyway.

Yes, it aggravates me when somebody’s cell phone rings off the imaginary hook at a restaurant or a movie. And yes, there are a lot of people who think (or more likely want us to think) they’re too crucial to the wheels of commerce to be off the grid for a hour (most of them like to wear sunglasses inside too). But notwithstanding those inconsiderate and insecure folks, there is a legitimate need to be reachable when you’re out at dinner and a movie.

Rather than ban or jam cell phones, establishments should develop and publish cell phone policies. The easy one is to require that all cell phones be put on silent mode during a movie and that anyone who wants to take a call must first go to the lobby. If someone really needs to tell someone something in the middle of a movie, send them a text message that does not disturb others.

If someone needs to talk to me, I want them to be able to reach me. It’s up to me, and every other right thinking person, to decide who really needs to talk to me now or who can wait an hour or two. And it’s up to me to take calls I need to take in a way that doesn’t disturb the people in the next row or at the next table.

The way to get there is via uniformly enforced cell phone policies and societal pressure- not via cell phone jamming and legislation.

Tags:

Down to 999,999

firefoxEd Bott says there’s one less reason to use Firefox, now that someone has made an add-on that replicates Firefox’s find box.

That’s a neat feature, but the fact remains that Firefox has left IE in the dust.  From time to time, IE might close the gap a little, but barring some radical open source move from Microsoft, the race for the power user is over.

One add-on to replicate one feature is simply not going to matter in the long run.  In the time it took to write that one add-on, hundreds of Firefox plugins were likely written, updated, etc.  There is too much developer support behind Firefox for IE to regain the momentum.

There are, of course, millions and millions of Windows users who don’t know anything about Firefox.  So it’s not like IE is going to fade into oblivion.

But I can’t think of a legitimate reason why a tech savvy power user would prefer IE over Firefox.

Tags: ,

RoamEO, RoamEO, Where Art Thou Dog

As more and more GPS devices come to market, we are seeing lots of devices that allow you to track cars, people and pets.  Gizmodo has a post about a new one.

The lastest is a pet tracker cleverly (or not) called RoamEO.  I think GPS for pets makes sense.  Lucky Dog has a one of those chips that allow him to be identified should he hop a plane to San Diego or something.  I’d consider using a GPS device as well.

But not one with a limit of 1 mile.  If he’s within a mile of home, he’s not so much lost as he is out for a walk.  Granted, if he was outside of that radius, I could drive around and hope to get a beep on the unit.  But that seems less than ideal- for pet control.

But boy oh boy would I love to have one of these for quail hunting.  The unit will tell you how fast your dog is moving, which probably sounds silly to anyone who isn’t a quail hunter.  You can track 3 dogs at the same time, which is also perfect for quail hunting.

The 1 mile limit is still a little short, but I’m intrigued by the possibilities.

Lucky Dog probably won’t get a RoamEO, but some of his hunting friends might.

Now someone just needs to invent a KidEO before my kids hit the teenage years.

Tags: , ,

Morning Reading: 9/7/06

Marcus Vorwaller on how to have better conversations.

Wired on the other side of the blogosphere.  “Creating your own blog is about as easy as creating your own urine, and you’re about as likely to find someone else interested in it.” 

Darren Rowse on keeping your digital camera out of harm’s way.

The Blackberry Pearl looks pretty sweet.  Wonder if it will ever come to Verizon?

Nick Carr on the Digg problem.

Richard Querin has some good thoughts about the boring blogosphere problem.

Here’s a niche product.  Web 2.0 seating charts.  I don’t know if I should laugh or cry.

Make yourself a logo.

Tags: ,

In Search of a More Conversational Blogosphere

The blogosphere is boring me lately, so I need to make some adjustments. I need to find a more conversational blogosphere.

conversation

My dilemma is the result of a couple of patterns. Stated simply, the first is a growing realization that I simply don’t care about a lot of the stuff that pops up in my RSS feeds lately. I don’t really care that Six Apart bought Rojo. I think pay per view movies on a cell phone is perhaps the silliest thing I’ve ever heard of. I can’t even muster enough interest to write a separate post about how silly it is.

I am tired of the same old same old. Dave Winer reminding us once again that he invented something people are talking about today a long time ago. I don’t really care that Dave invented everything we talk about. Good for him. I’m just bored with hearing about it.

Is there any place for modesty in the blogosphere- or has it become one giant billboard for self-promotion?

I’m weary of hearing people who have done everything they can do to raise their profile in the blogosphere proclaim that they don’t care about traffic. Let some of those folks talk to themselves for about a week and see how they feel. It’s perfectly OK to raise your image and try to become influential among the hundreds of people who care what a blogger thinks. But it is hypocritical on its face to then turn around and say traffic (the blogosphere’s attention equivalent) isn’t important to you.

If people won’t be intellectually honest about their intentions, is there a basis for conversation?

I’m bored with reading the latest cheerleader report on how Web 2.0 is big business poised to change the world. No one seems to see beyond the boundaries of the blogosphere. It’s cool if you really think the next social bookmarking service is going to change the world. I’m just tired of hearing it- particularly from people with skin in the game. We’ve talked about the easily identified conflicts of interest in the blogopshere, but the less obvious ones are a bigger, and growing, problem.

It just seems like the blogosphere is becoming an online series of tupperware parties where friends move money around amongst themselves while they wait for the mythical third party tupperware lover to show up. It’s Eugene O’Neill, Stanley Kubrick style.

echo chamber

The second troubling pattern is the echo chamber that we talk about from time to time. Some self or temporally appointed smart guy says something that is supposed to be clever or earth-shattering and then, like the anchovies at the Krusty Krab, tons of others pile out of the bus and say the same thing. With so many people saying the same thing, conversations are simply not possible. There’s just the drone of a hundred keyboards typing the same words.

And finally, I’m exhausted from trying to have conversations with people who don’t share my view of the blogosphere as conversational. Blogging is a lot of different stuff for a lot of different people. For me, it’s not about spouting off my latest philosophy and it’s certainly not about making money. It’s supposed to be about having fun. It’s supposed to be about learning stuff and sharing interests. The more I think about it, using blogging as a way to make money or become influential is, well, boring. Can’t we just be regular people and talk about interesting stuff? Sure we can. If we make an effort to seek out like-minded individuals.

It’s not wrong to think of the blogosphere differently than I do. Good luck to those who think blogging is going to make them rich or famous or get them a Wikipedia entry. It’s just more fun to find people who come at the blogging thing from a similar place.

So I have decided to seek out a more conversational blogosphere. Gone from my blogroll will be those whose primary purpose, be it disclosed or not, is wealth accumulation or self-aggrandizement. I would find those people boring in the real world. The fact that they found the little room at the end of the hall before me doesn’t make them any less boring.

In sum, I either have to fix my blogging outlook or stand by and watch my blogging interest go to zero the way so many of my stocks did back in Bubble 1.0

I want to find, link to and converse with the sort of people I’d enjoy talking to in the real world. I’m going to need some help finding them. But I’m pretty committed to this new manifesto.

I’m interested in tech, obviously. And I think much of the Web 2.0 stuff is cool- taken in the right context. I’m interested in music, movies, humor, photography and self-expression in general. I want to talk and learn about that stuff. I’m tired of talking at people who aren’t listening and I’m concerned that by doing that, I am missing out on better and more useful conversations that are happening somewhere else.

It’s going to be a bit of trial and error and it may completely fail. I may end up in an even smaller room all by myself. But I have to try.

Otherwise, my blog is going to wither and die out of sheer boredom.

I’m going to have some space on my blogroll. If you know of anyone interesting I should add, let me know.

Tags: , ,

Windows Live Writer Annoyance

Beta or not, I simply cannot understand why there is a need to add a post (which I have found no easy way to delete) on your blog every time you install Live Writer.

I just installed it on my laptop and, presto, there’s another “temporary” post I can’t get rid of.

This needs to be seems to have been fixed.

Update: When I posted using Live Writer, the temporary post seems to have disappeared.

Tags: