MacJournal as a Blogging App: So Much Potential, So Much Frustration

macjI continue to keep Parallels and a Windows 7 installation on my iMac, solely so I can use Live Writer. Lately, however, I’ve experienced a lot of unexpected Windows restarts and other (Windows-related) crashes. This adversely affects my joy and greatly increases my interest in finding a decent Mac blogging app, so I can uninstall Parallels and rid myself of the last remnant of Windows.

So I was immediately interested when I came across MacJournal today.

It’s not specifically a blogging app, but it has blogging features that are noted in the write-up and in the user manual. It is clearly a powerful app, that does a lot of things very well. It has good ratings, and seems to be beloved by many as a journaling tool.  But as a blogging app, it has issues.  Some of them are serious.

Need an example? How about the fact that this is the fourth time I’ve written this blog post- the first three tries via MacJournal were lost to a spinning beach ball of lockups. This one is being written in good ol’ Live Writer.  I wish I was raving about the many good features MacJournal has to offer.  Instead, I am  ranting about the lost potential.  And the fact that I can’t yet rid my iMac of Windows.

Let’s take a look at the very good and the very bad.

The good:

1. It is designed to interface well with a self-hosted WordPress installation. Setting up the blog connection is as easy as adding the URL, name and password for your blog.

2. It’s easy to add links, though the app needs to paste any URLs on the clipboard into the URL box. A small thing, yes, but a real time saver.

3. It is generally easy to add and manipulate photos and videos. There needs to be an easy way to resize a photo to a specific width, etc.

4. Categories and tags are supported.

5. I think it would be easy to create time saving templates.  When it comes to adding content and media, the app is very powerful.

Adding photos is as easy as a drag and drop, or you can browse through the included media browser to find media on your Mac.

Adding YouTube videos is even easier.   Paste the iframe code into your post, and MacJournal does the rest. This is very handy.

You can also record audio and video entries right from the app.

You can quickly import audio and video files from your Mac.

The bad:

notresp

This happens a lot. It’s a deal stopper for me.  The problems seem to arise mostly when I try to publish a media-rich blog post. Problems also arise when I try to open an existing unpublished entry to edit it.

loading

Forever loading. Loading. Forever.

I was never able to successfully publish a media rich blog post via MacJournal.  My initial test post, containing just a photo and a YouTube video published quickly and easily, and looked great.  I could even edit it and republish it.  After that, when I tried to do a full post, with a photo, a YouTube video, several links and a short voice recording, nothing.  Just this.

nopublish

There are some quirks in the editing window (the cursor jumps to the top when you try to resize an image below the fold; I don’t see an easy way to make links open in a new tab or window, etc.), but those are minor annoyances that don’t outweigh the app’s obvious potential. That is, if you could actually post to your blog.

Granted, I am focusing on one aspect of what is, essentially, a journaling app.  But that is the one feature I want, and the only reason I would pay $30 (wow) for the app.

The local journaling features may work fine, but as a blogging app, MacJournal is frustrating, to say the least, and possibly broken (if these issues I am experiencing are widespread; I hope they are not).  The lockups and inability to open an existing entry are huge problems. The worst part is that MacJournal clearly has a ton of potential.  But for now its greatest potential is to frustrate those looking for a native Mac app to replace Live Writer.

Hopefully someone will create a decent Mac blogging app at some point.  I need to get Windows off of my iMac.  Soon.

One response to “MacJournal as a Blogging App: So Much Potential, So Much Frustration

  1. Ahh.. pity mate. I didn’t have those lockup issues at all. Then I didn’t try audio and heavy post. I did do youtube, images and links.

    You can resize an image via right-click.

    And you can add a link by dragging the icon from the address bar straight into the post.

    Still I acknowledge it has shortcomings.. but lots of potential in the MarinerSoftware guys would change focus a little and add a few blog-centric features – it’d be a winner.